PCOS: what the guidelines actually say — SMOODI

‘Lose some weight and come back in six months’

Roughly a third of the women I know have PCOS, and they all ask me the same question — so I sat down with the doctors on our advisory board and we went through the guidelines together. Here is the honest version, including the bits that make my own product look less impressive.

Simona at her kitchen counter
Two in the morning, on a work night. This is, embarrassingly, where a lot of it starts.

Friends. Women I meet at events. Women I’ve known for years who mention it halfway through a conversation about something else entirely, in the same tone you’d use to mention a bad landlord.

And every time, the same shape. A long stretch of being told it’s nothing. Then a diagnosis. Then a wall of advice arriving from every direction at once.

The question they ask is never the one you’d expect.

Not “what is inositol.” They know what inositol is. It’s “which of all this am I supposed to believe?”

These are women who have read the forums, listened to the podcasts, bought the supplements and tried the diet. They don’t need more information. They need somebody to be straight with them about which bits are actually solid.

So we went through the guidelines properly

Not the Instagram summaries of the guidelines. The actual documents, with the two GPs on our advisory board — because I am not qualified to interpret clinical guidance on my own, and I’m not about to pretend otherwise on a page where I’m also selling something.

For the record, my own diagnosis isn’t PCOS. Mine is its own complicated mess and I’ll spare you the details. But I recognised the machinery immediately, because it’s the same three levers I spent the better part of a decade learning about the hard way — at two in the morning, on work nights, like a normal and well-adjusted person. And the same experience of being handed one option and a follow-up appointment in six months.

What follows is what we found, written the way I’d have wanted somebody to write it for me.

What’s actually happening, in plain terms

PCOS isn’t one thing going wrong. It’s three things going wrong in a way that keeps them going wrong.

Your body stops responding properly to insulin. So it makes more of it. Insulin runs high.

That extra insulin pushes up testosterone. Which is where the acne, the unwanted hair growth and the thinning on top come from.

And your cycle stops behaving. Irregular, late, missing entirely — because the hormonal picture interferes with ovulation.

Then it loops. Insulin pushes testosterone up, testosterone disrupts the cycle, and the whole metabolic strain makes the insulin part harder to shift again.

Which is precisely why treating one symptom at a time feels like bailing out a boat with a teaspoon. You’re not imagining that. It genuinely is a circle.

For the record: roughly one in ten women of reproductive age, and by the WHO’s estimate up to seventy per cent of them never get diagnosed at all. So if it took you years, you are not an outlier. You’re the norm.

Please go and see a doctor

I want to be unusually direct here, because this is where wellness content gets quietly irresponsible and I don’t want to be part of that.

PCOS is treatable, and the treatment with the strongest evidence behind it is medical. The pill is first-line for cycle irregularity and the testosterone-driven symptoms. Metformin has real evidence for the metabolic side. There are fertility treatments with good track records where that matters.

None of that is a compromise. It is the thing that works best, according to the people who study this for a living.

If you suspect PCOS and haven’t had a proper workup, that is worth more than anything on this page, including the bit where I sell you something.

Before I go any further

I’m not against conventional medicine, and I’m not saying holistic medicine is the answer. What I am saying is that we have to advocate for ourselves and try to get to the bottom of it.

This is not medical advice. It’s my reading of published guidelines. I’d be the first person to tell you to speak to your GP.

What you get told, and what the guideline actually says

What you get told
  • “There’s a specific PCOS diet.”
  • “You need to do this exact type of exercise.”
  • “Just lose the weight first.”
  • “The mood stuff is separate.”
  • “Stress management is a nice extra.”
What the guideline says
  • No eating pattern has been shown to beat the others. Sustainable matters more than specific.
  • No type or intensity of exercise outperforms another. Regular movement is the recommendation.
  • Weight is part of care where relevant, and it explicitly says to handle it without stigma.
  • Depression and anxiety are significantly more common with PCOS, and screening is recommended in the document itself.
  • Stress and sleep interact with the same insulin pathway. Not an add-on.

I found that last column genuinely liberating, and I suspect you might too. A lot of the pressure you’ve been carrying about doing PCOS correctly isn’t in the clinical guidance at all.

The bit most people skip

Stress isn’t a mood. It’s a mechanism.

“Manage your stress” is the most infuriating advice on earth when it arrives with no explanation attached. So here’s the explanation.

Cortisol raises blood sugar. That’s its actual job — it tells the liver to release glucose, and insulin comes along to deal with it. Now run that on a loop, every day, in a body where insulin is already the weak link.

It runs the other way too. High insulin drives more testosterone, which is the same lever everything else in the syndrome is pulling on.

And it isn’t theoretical. A study in 2022 measured cortisol in hair, which reflects weeks of exposure rather than one bad Tuesday. Women with PCOS averaged roughly double the control group.

So stress isn’t sitting next to your PCOS care. It’s pulling the same lever as food and movement.

Which is annoying, because it’s much easier to change what you eat than to change your entire working life. I know. I’m aware of the irony of a woman who built a company saying this.

Working through it Skin, treated on its own Another appointment

The most boring thing on this page, and the best evidenced

Muscle is where most of your food ends up going after a meal. When insulin is released, muscle tissue takes the large majority of that glucose out of the bloodstream — published estimates put it around eighty per cent.

Which means muscle isn’t a cosmetic project. It’s metabolic infrastructure. It is the single biggest place your body has to put sugar.

Protein is how you build and hold onto it, and leucine — the amino acid in protein most responsible for triggering muscle building — is the specific bit that matters. There’s also research showing leucine taken alongside glucose blunts the blood sugar spike compared with glucose on its own.

I bring this up because almost every PCOS conversation I’ve ever had sprints straight to supplements and skips this. Protein and muscle are less exciting than a capsule with a good story. They’re also better established.

Now the supplements, honestly

This is the section that costs me sales, and I’d rather lose you here than after you’ve spent money.

Inositol. The most-studied one, and the one you have almost certainly already bought. It’s involved in how cells respond to insulin. But the 2023 review that fed into the international guideline calls the evidence limited and inconclusive, and found metformin came out better for weight and metabolic markers.

I’m telling you that while selling a drink that contains inositol. Make of that what you will.

Chromium. Studied for insulin sensitivity in PCOS specifically, with a randomised controlled trial behind it.

Zinc. Involved in how the body handles testosterone. A placebo-controlled trial in 48 women using 50mg a day for eight weeks reported improvements in hair loss and unwanted hair growth. Worth saying plainly: that dose is far above what any food supplement blend contains, including mine.

Vitamin D. Deficiency is common with PCOS and there are several reviews looking at supplementation.

Antioxidants and B vitamins. Oxidative stress and low-grade inflammation are now recognised as part of the picture, which is the reasoning behind vitamins C and E. B6, B12 and folate come up for hormone metabolism, and folate matters especially if you’re trying to conceive.

Two more come up constantly and are not in what I make: omega-3 and NAC. I’m mentioning them anyway, because a list that only contains what I happen to sell isn’t a list, it’s an advert.

One powder does not fix PCOS. Anyone telling you otherwise is either guessing or counting on you not checking.

So where does a drink fit in

Not as treatment. Let me put that on its own line.

Here’s the honest answer, and it’s a boring practical one rather than a medical one.

Everything above — protein, blood sugar, stress, sleep, movement, having decent nutrient levels — is foundations. Foundations only work if you keep doing them. And keeping doing them is where most of us fall over. Certainly where I did.

Fifteen bottles. Four alarms. A pill organiser I bought and then quietly resented. By Wednesday of most weeks I’d given up on half of it, and my morning had turned into an admin task with a checklist.

That’s the problem I could actually solve. Not the syndrome. The shelf.

The best supplement in the world is useless if you forget to take it.

What I made

One vanilla drink. Thirty seconds. Every morning.

SMOODI pouch, vanilla, 800g
SMOODI®
Vanilla · 25g protein and the eight things I used to buy in separate bottles, in one scoop.
£85
800g pouch · one month
  • Formulated specifically for women from the start
  • Doesn’t taste of beef, doesn’t go gritty
  • Built with two GPs and two nutritionists
  • Recipes developed by a Le Cordon Bleu trained chef

I have opinions about every single item in here and I’ll happily tell you why each one earned its place. Nothing is in it because it looks good on a label.

Per serving Why it earned its place
25g grass-fed beef protein Contributes to the growth and maintenance of muscle mass, and the maintenance of normal bones
Vitamin B6 Contributes to the regulation of hormonal activity, and to the reduction of tiredness and fatigue
Chromium Contributes to the maintenance of normal blood glucose levels
Zinc Contributes to normal cognitive function, and the maintenance of normal hair, skin and nails
Vitamin D3 Contributes to normal muscle function and normal immune function
Vitamin B12 Contributes to the reduction of tiredness and fatigue
Folate Contributes to normal psychological function
Vitamin C Contributes to the reduction of tiredness and fatigue, and protects cells from oxidative stress
Vitamin A Contributes to the maintenance of normal skin
Vitamin E Protects cells from oxidative stress
Vitamin K2 Contributes to the maintenance of normal bones

There are a few more things in there — inositol, rhodiola, L-theanine, a kiwifruit complex, artichoke, bromelain, MCT. I’ve deliberately not written a benefit next to those, because in the UK there’s no authorised health claim for them and I’m not going to invent one. They’re on the label. Go and read about them somewhere that isn’t trying to sell you anything.

The one hormonal claim I can actually make, I’ll make properly: vitamin B6 contributes to the regulation of hormonal activity. That’s the sentence. That’s all of it.

One scoop, going in
One scoop, milk or alt-milk, done. This is the entire routine.
Buy SMOODI · £85
800g pouch · one month · vanilla
Who built it with me

I had the vision. That doesn’t mean I had every answer.

I’ve spent enough money being sold things by people with no qualifications to have very strong feelings about this. So I got the qualifications into the room rather than performing them.

Dr Rumbi Mutenga Dr N. K. Rocsi Chereches Laura Marricks

The advisory board

  • Dr Rumbi Mutenga — GP and scientific advisor. Resident doctor in general practice, former midwife.
  • Dr N. K. — GP and scientific advisor. Over a decade in practice, and a functional medicine practitioner. For now she stays behind the scenes.
  • Rocsi Chereches — menstrual cycle nutritionist and TEDx Salon speaker.
  • Laura Marricks — holistic nutritionist, Le Cordon Bleu London trained. She developed every SMOODI recipe.

Four women with different expertise, different perspectives, and the confidence to challenge mine. Doing women’s health responsibly means knowing when to listen, when to question, and who deserves a seat at the table.

The questions I’d ask, if I were you

“Is this a PCOS supplement?”

No. It’s a protein drink with a considered micronutrient formula, made for women. Several of the nutrients in it are ones that come up in PCOS nutrition research. That is a different sentence to “this treats PCOS,” and I’m not going to blur the two, however much easier that would make my life.

“I already take inositol. Do I need both?”

Possibly not, and that’s a conversation for whoever manages your care rather than for me. If you’re on a therapeutic dose somebody put you on deliberately, please don’t change it because a website told you to.

“Can I take this with metformin, or the pill?”

Ask your GP or pharmacist first — genuinely, not as a disclaimer. Everything in it is printed on the label so you can take that with you. Not intended for anyone under 18, or if you’re pregnant or breastfeeding.

“Will beef protein taste disgusting?”

No, and I get why you’re asking. The industry seems to think you have to choose between something that tastes like a bag of sweets and something you force down like medicine. I never understood who decided those were the options. A Le Cordon Bleu trained chef developed the recipes and we rejected a great many of them.

“Has anyone other than you actually used it?”

Around a hundred women have been drinking it while we tested and reformulated, and their feedback is the reason the recipe changed as many times as it did. What I don’t have yet is a wall of five-star reviews, because this is the first batch at any real scale — and I’d rather tell you that than borrow somebody else’s.

“What if I stop taking it, like I stop taking everything?”

That’s the honest question, and it’s the one the whole thing is built around. I stopped taking six things by Wednesday, every week, for years. One drink, thirty seconds, in the slot where breakfast already goes — that’s the only version I ever managed to keep.

Reasons you’ll either buy this, or absolutely not

  • I’ll tell you when your favourite supplement is a waste of money
  • I think your protein should do more than build your glutes
  • I’m against fifteen-step routines that nobody keeps past Thursday
  • I don’t believe in quick fixes
  • I read science papers before bed and I will bring them up unprompted
  • I still order dessert

If any of that makes you uncomfortable, we probably won’t get along. And that’s okay. I didn’t build this to tell women what they want to hear. If you’re here for evidence over hype, welcome.

Buy SMOODI · £85
One month · vanilla · made in the UK

If you take one thing from this page, I’d honestly rather it were the paragraph about seeing a doctor than the one about my drink.

PCOS is common, it’s complicated, and it is treatable. You deserve somebody who will look at the whole picture instead of handing you one option and a six-month wait. I can’t be that person.

What I can do is be straight with you about what I know, what the evidence says, and where it runs out. And make the mornings slightly less of an admin task while you get on with the rest of it.

Anyway. That’s the pitch, such as it is. I did warn you I’d talk about this more than anyone asked me to.

— Simona

Buy SMOODI
£85 · 800g pouch · one month

SMOODI is a food supplement. Food supplements should not be used as a substitute for a varied and balanced diet and a healthy lifestyle. Not intended for anyone under 18, or for women who are pregnant or breastfeeding. If you are taking medication or under medical supervision, speak to your doctor before use.

This page is general information about published research and the founder’s reading of it. It is not medical advice, and no product described here is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any condition. Advertorial.

SMOODI® · £85 · one month
Buy now